Skip to Main Content

State of Elections

A student-run blog from the Election Law Society

Preemptive Electoral Challenges in Waynesboro, Virginia: A Clear Illustration of Widespread Administrative Tension

November 5, 2024

By: Sophie Tully

Election certification litigation is rampant in Virginia just days before many voters go to the polls on Election Day.

Waynesboro election board members Curtis Lilly and Scott Mares filed a lawsuit in Waynesboro Circuit Court on October 4th claiming they would refuse to certify the November election without hand-counted ballots due to concerns with voting machines. Voters responded with their own lawsuit on October 22nd against those election officials for their pledge not to verify the election. 

(more…)

Topics: Ballot Custody Certification and Reporting Results Vote Counting and Canvassing

Maine Ballot Initiative Aims to Tee Up a Supreme Court Ruling on Super PACs

November 5, 2024

By: John Thayer

When Maine voters go to the polls on Tuesday, November 5, they will get to vote on a ballot initiative that poses a straightforward question: “Do you want to set a $5,000 limit for giving to political action committees that spend money independently to support or defeat candidates for office?” Maine Question 1, the Limit Contributions to Super PACs Initiative, has received bipartisan support. According to a recent poll from Pan Atlantic Research, 69% of respondents said they intend to vote “yes” on the initiative (limiting PAC contributions), with 15% of respondents saying they intend to vote “no” and 16% indicating they were undecided. Maine’s federal congressional delegation (consisting of Democrats Chellie Pingree from the 1st District and Jared Golden from the 2nd District) support the initiative, as do state legislators on both sides of the aisle. 

(more…)

Topics: Initiatives and Referenda Political Committee Requirements

Iowa Supreme Court Sends a Strong Message of Strict Compliance with Election Laws in Recent Ballot Access Decision

November 4, 2024

By: William & Mary Law Student Contributor

The Iowa Supreme Court has completed its expedited review of a district court ruling upholding the State Objection Panel’s decision to remove three Libertarian candidates for the US House of Representatives from the 2024 general election ballot. This decision comes in just before the Wednesday, September 11 11:59 p.m. deadline for finalizing the names on the general election ballot. The Supreme Court affirmed the decision by the Panel to remove their names from the general election ballot due to a failure to comply with statutory nomination requirements. The candidates did not dispute that their nomination process did not comply with Iowa Code §43.94, but they did raise several alternative grounds that the Panel erred in striking their name from the November ballots. The Supreme Court discussed these grounds and took the opportunity to deliver a strong message of strict compliance with election laws.

(more…)

Topics: Ballot Access – Candidate U.S. Congressional

Chaos or Federalism: Section 3 Enforcement in Illinois

November 4, 2024

By: Matthias Connelly

Before the Supreme Court heard oral arguments in Trump v. Anderson, commentators worried about the political implications of deciding whether Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment disqualified former President Trump from holding office for his having engaged in insurrection within the Section’s meaning. After oral argument, it was apparent where the Justices had coalesced in their decision-making: what sort of electoral chaos would different disqualification decisions by different states relating to different candidates produce?

(more…)

Topics: Election Board Qualifications – Candidates U.S. Presidential

Equal Protection Will Not Give U.S. Territories A Vote in Federal Elections

November 4, 2024

By: Adam Russell

On August 30, 2024, the Ninth Circuit invalidated a group of territorial residents’ equal protection claims in Borja v. Nago. The court’s decision was partially based on the fact that former residents of a state who move to U.S. Territories are not a suspect class, and are therefore subject to rational basis review. However, the court did not exclude the possibility that residents born in U.S. Territories could be a part of a suspect class protected by a higher level of judicial scrutiny. In fact, it even acknowledged that these residents might meet the definition of a suspect class. The majority wrote, “many residents of U.S. Territories ‘have endured a long history of discrimination’ on account of their place of birth, race, or ethnicity.” In 1973 the Supreme Court, by comparison, defined a suspect class as a group “saddled with such disabilities, or subjected to such a history of purposeful unequal treatment, or relegated to such a position of political powerlessness as to command extraordinary protection from the majoritarian political process.” This begs the question: can the equal protection guarantee of the Constitution give certain Territorial resident’s the vote? Honestly, probably not. 

(more…)

Topics: Federal Elections Voting Rights

Potential Drawbacks of Georgia’s New Hand Tabulation Requirement

November 1, 2024

By: Hailey Arnett

Georgia has been a key battleground state for decades, and in 2020, the Democratic presidential candidate Joe Biden won the state’s electoral votes by a narrow margin of around 12,000 votes. When the margin between candidates was less than 0.5%, Georgia law permitted but did not require a recount. For the presidential race in Georgia, the margin between the candidates was only 0.2% before the post-election hand count. Therefore, Brad Raffensperger, Georgia’s Secretary of State, requested a hand count of Georgia ballots after the election, or a “risk limiting audit,” to ensure the accuracy of the electronic counting. After the post-election hand count, the Associated Press called Georgia for presidential candidate Joe Biden. For the first time in nearly thirty years, Georgia went blue for the presidential race.

(more…)

Topics: Certification and Reporting Results Vote Counting and Canvassing

Connecticut’s Campaign Financing Rules Clash with Free Speech Rights

November 1, 2024

By: Jayli Esber

Courts must ensure that campaign finance regulations, intended to promote democracy, do not inadvertently threaten the democratic cornerstone of free speech. In Markley v. State Elections Enforcement Commission, decided May 20, 2024, the Connecticut Supreme Court held that the state’s public financing program had upset this balance. The regulations for the program provide that all funds must “directly further” the recipient’s election campaign. The State Elections Enforcement Commission (“SEEC”), which oversees the program, issued an Advisory Opinion explaining that funds could not be used for communications that promote the defeat of or attack a candidate who is not a direct opponent of the recipient.

(more…)

Topics: Campaign Finance Candidate Requirements Public Funding

Kentucky’s Amendment One: What It Means for Noncitizen Voting Rights

November 1, 2024

By: Olivia Rovin

This year on election day in Kentucky, the ballot will have two constitutional amendments. The one causing the most controversy is the proposed Amendment One which states as follows:

Every citizen of the United States of the age of eighteen years who has resided in the state one year, and in the county six months, and the precinct in which he or she offers to vote sixty days next preceding the election, shall be a voter in said precinct and not elsewhere. No person who is not a citizen of the United States shall be allowed to vote in this state. The following persons also shall not have the right to vote:

(more…)

Topics: Constitutional Amendment or Revision Voter Eligibility Voting Rights

Navigating Candidate Withdrawals: The Legal Implications of Late-Stage Ballot Changes in North Carolina

November 1, 2024

By: Sarah Catherine Woodruff

In this election cycle, discussion of candidates’ names being added and removed from the ballot has been particularly salient, beginning with claims that it would be “unlawful” to remove Biden as the Democratic Presidential nominee and replace his name with Harris after Biden won the Democratic primary. This concern was addressed relatively quickly, as the events occurred in July, creating no legal or constitutional problem with changing the ballots as the Democratic candidate had not been officially nominated yet, and state ballot deadlines would not be violated. However, removing Robert F. Kennedy Jr. (RFK) as a presidential candidate from the North Carolina ballot has proved to be a much greater challenge with legitimate legal concerns due to RFK’s late withdrawal from the race. On August 29th, the NC State Board of Elections rejected a request to remove the We The People Party nominee RFK from the general election ballot. 

(more…)

Topics: Ballot Access – Candidate Candidates and Parties Withdrawal

In Pennsylvania, Every Vote Counts, But Is Every Vote Counted? 

October 31, 2024

By: Natalie Hatton

Imagine a voter in Pennsylvania, an essential swing state in the upcoming presidential election. Imagine he decides to vote by mail because he is immunocompromised, he lives far from his polling place, or he will be out of town in November. He fills out his ballot but misdates the outer envelope, writing his date of birth instead of today’s date. He puts it in the mail weeks ahead of the deadline. Will his vote be counted? Will his county board of elections notify him of the error and allow him to cure his ballot? The answer: it depends.  (more…)

Topics: Ballot Rejection and Curing Vote by Mail and Absentee Voting